Instagram LinkedIn X Youtube
Back to Blog

Hold the Strategy for a Year and Let the Tactics Change

If you pitch a strategy to a client, you should be convicted enough in it to run it for a year.

That doesn’t mean you’re closed to iteration or pivots. It means you believe this is what it’s going to take to hit the objective. Otherwise you wouldn’t have pitched it, and the client wouldn’t have bought it.

I’ve been saying this a lot lately to account teams who are good at their jobs and still end up rebuilding the plan every few months. The habit is common enough that most agencies don’t see it as a habit at all.

The 90-day reset is built into how most agencies plan

A lot of agencies plan in 90-day sprints. That part is fine. The trouble starts the week before the quarterly meeting, when the team sits down to prepare and the first question on the table is what’s wrong. What’s not working? Then they walk into the meeting and pitch a whole new thing.

Think about what that does to the strategy. You gave yourself three months to build momentum with a set of strategies, and when they didn’t pan out in 90 days, you scrapped them and moved on to something else. Plenty of strategies can’t show what they’re worth in three months. SEO can’t. Content can’t. When a client wants to test LinkedIn for $500 over 30 days, my honest answer is that they’d be better off keeping the $500, because 30 days isn’t long enough to learn anything.

It happens between quarters too. A client asks about AEO, or about blogs, and the account manager says “oh yeah, we do that.” Budget moves from one line to another. Nobody on the account is convicted in the strategy, so it never stops moving.

Conviction belongs at the strategy level

Once you’ve aligned with the client on the objective, the strategy shouldn’t change often. That’s the part you commit to for about a year.

The tactics underneath have a lot more room to move. That’s the ground level: which pages get written this sprint, which campaigns run, which audiences get tested. Some of it will miss, and you should swap it out when it does. Some of it takes a while to play out, and you need the patience to let it.

When those two levels blur together, every tactic that misses turns into a vote on the whole strategy. One flat month on a campaign becomes a conversation about whether the client should be running paid at all.

“What’s not working?” might not be the right question

I won’t say it’s the wrong question. But I don’t know if it’s the right one, because it skips two things nobody defined at the start. What does working mean, and on what timeline did we expect it to be working?

I’ve seen a client tell an agency “this isn’t working, we’re not getting anything” in the same month the Google Ads team reported that conversion rates and cost per action were both improving. Both sides were telling the truth. They were measuring different things, and nobody had written down which number the client cared about or when it was supposed to move.

So when a client says it isn’t working, I’d rather ask:

Those questions keep the conversation on the plan instead of on a replacement for it.

Accountability runs both ways

That last question is the uncomfortable one, and it’s meant to be. Accountability can have friction, but it doesn’t have to mean conflict.

Sometimes the answer is that the agency didn’t deliver. The pages shipped late, the tracking never got fixed, the campaign launched a month behind. That’s on you, and it’s what you fix first. Other times the client didn’t send the approvals, didn’t follow up on the leads the way they agreed to, or pulled budget halfway through. That’s on them, and saying so plainly is part of keeping the strategy alive long enough to win.

Without that question, the agency absorbs all of it, and the easiest way to absorb it is to pitch something new.

“But what if the strategy is wrong?”

Then change it. Holding a strategy for a year doesn’t mean ignoring what the numbers tell you.

What matters is the reason for the change. A strategy should come off the table because the numbers you agreed on say it’s wrong, after enough time for them to move, with the tactics under it done. It shouldn’t come off because a quarterly meeting is coming up and the team needs something new to present.

If you can’t tell which one you’re looking at, the objective and the timeline usually never got written down in the first place. Fix that, and the next “it isn’t working” conversation gets a lot easier.

What it costs to keep starting over

Every reset costs you twice. The team spends hours building a new plan instead of running the old one, and the old plan never gets the time it needed. Reset every quarter and the client pays for four first quarters a year and never sees a second one.

Clients notice that too. They may not put it this way, but an agency that changes direction every 90 days starts to look like an agency that isn’t sure what it’s doing, even when each new plan sounds smart in the room.

Pitch the strategy you believe in and commit to it for a year. Let the tactics move as much as they need to, and give the strategy the time it takes to win.